The Ethical Dilemma Surrounding Self-Driving Cars

by

Self-driving cars, also known as autonomous vehicles, are transforming the way we travel. However, with this advancement comes a significant concern for safety and responsibility. In a research article published in the Journal of Information Technology, Professor Michael Myers and his co-authors delve into the issues of trustworthiness and the allocation of responsibility in autonomous driving, focusing specifically on ethical and legal safety challenges.

According to the researchers, there are troubling contradictions in how responsibility is assigned in supposedly safe autonomous systems. This confusion and lack of clarity indicate an ongoing issue with understanding how responsibility should be shared among the various parties involved.

A notable case that highlights the uncertainty surrounding responsibility in accidents involving autonomous vehicles is the 2016 Tesla crash. Initially, the United States National Transportation Safety Board attributed the crash to human error. However, the safety body later revised its decision and criticized Tesla for allowing the activation of autopilot on roads that were not suitable for the feature.

Professor Myers points out that autonomous driving systems are complex and carry significant risks. This is evident in the recent massive recall of over two million Teslas. It is ironic that, while automation aims to allow individuals to relax instead of driving, the driver still needs to actively monitor the system in case it is not fully autonomous. Unfortunately, drivers are not always vigilant, leading to serious safety concerns.

According to Professor Myers, monitoring autonomous driving systems requires human understanding, but the National Transportation Safety Board states that humans are notoriously inefficient at doing so. Moreover, as technology advances, individuals may become deskilled, lacking the necessary skills to react appropriately in the event of an issue.

Furthermore, vehicles often come preloaded with software that is regularly updated. Despite manufacturers promoting automation, individuals have little control over the level of automation in their vehicles and limited knowledge of how it operates. Consequently, if an accident occurs, blame is often directed at the driver.

However, the driver may not be aware of their level of control in emergency situations. As self-driving technology continues to develop, it is crucial to address the question of liability in the event of a crash.

One of the challenges in testing automated driving systems is their dependence on the external environment. These systems cannot be tested in every possible scenario, making them unpredictable in the face of unfamiliar conditions such as extreme weather, wildlife, or unfamiliar road conditions.

Professor Myers emphasizes the need for a comprehensive understanding of the consequences of automation before rushing headlong into its implementation. He calls for research that critically examines the social, political, and technical aspects of autonomous driving systems, especially regarding safety, responsibility, and trust.

In conclusion, the rise of self-driving cars presents ethical dilemmas surrounding responsibility and safety. The current confusion in assigning responsibility and the lack of clarity in understanding the operation of autonomous systems highlight the need for further research and critical examination of these systems. As autonomous driving technology progresses, it is vital to address the complexities surrounding liability and ensure the safety and trustworthiness of these vehicles.

*Note:
1. Source: Coherent Market Insights, Public sources, Desk research
2. We have leveraged AI tools to mine information and compile it

Ravina
+ posts

Ravina Pandya,  Content Writer, has a strong foothold in the market research industry. She specializes in writing well-researched articles from different industries, including food and beverages, information and technology, healthcare, chemical and materials, etc. With an MBA in E-commerce, she has an expertise in SEO-optimized content that resonates with industry professionals.